All American Title Services

Attorney Owned and Operated

Your comprehensive title company—
Licensed throughout the state of Florida

Relax. We’ll take care of everything.

Let’s be honest. No one looks forward to the title insurance process. We get it. We are attorney owned and our staff is the best of the best. That’s how we can make this painless and simple. Our people are not only experts, they sweat details. We are proactive, friendly, and responsive. We anticipate and handle every contingency or nuance to keep you informed, and hopefully relaxed. Our goal is to give you the best, stress-free experience possible—especially if you are a first-time homeowner. Best of all, we are competitively priced and focused on providing customers with an unparalleled level of service.


To be Florida’s go-to title insurance company — for all homeowners, buyers, and sellers.


To be a proactive title insurance company that takes the pain out of your title process.

Meet Our Team

Thomas M. Tarsia


Thomas M. Tarsia is a life-long resident of Cape Coral. He is the founder of the company and serves as its Managing Member. Mr. Tarsia also is an attorney with a local law firm, where he concentrates his practice in real estate-related matters, estate planning, probate and business law.

Angela Petrick

Licensed Title Agent

Angela has been a Licensed Title Agent serving Southwest Florida since 2012. She’s known for her amazing communicating skills between all parties, making the closing process smooth and seamless for everyone involved. In her off time, Angela enjoys spending her time with her husband of 13 years, Ben, and their two sons, Noah and Eli. Crossfit, mountain biking, and camping are also among her favorite pastimes!

Kelly Robertson


Kelly Robertson is our Processor here at All American Title Services. She has been working in the Title Industry since 2016 and is a Licensed Notary. Prior to working in Title, Kelly worked as a Licensed Real Estate Agent so she is familiar with many aspects of the closing process. A Southwest Florida resident since 1982, Kelly is proud to call Southwest Florida her home! Her favorite pastimes include shopping, shopping, and more shopping, as well as spending time with her husband and kids.

Taylor Pudlin

Post Closer

As rare as they might be nowadays, Taylor is a Florida native who jumped into the title industry right out of college. She enjoys being part of a collaborative team and having the daily opportunity to support her clients. During her downtime, Taylor loves spending time with her fiancé, their amazing son, and three dogs.

Jennifer Hollow

Office Manager

Jennifer is originally from Sweden but has called Florida her home for the past 15 years. Because of her love for numbers, during college, Jennifer sought out a career in accounting. Jennifer found an interest in the Real Estate field 7 years ago and has been in the title industry for the last 2 years. In her free time, she enjoys spending time with her son and finding new adventures.

Kaitlin Tardif

Administrative Coordinator

Kaitlin is a Cape Coral native. She is new to All American Title and is eager to learn and grow in the industry. In her free time, she enjoys shopping, going to the beach, and spending time with her family and boyfriend.

Please use this form to contact our office directly.

All inquiries are responded to within 24 hours.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
(239) 242-2020